Saturday, June 23, 2007

Roberts and Recchi

Excellent, but....

Both off and on the ice, Ray Shero delivered excellent news when he announced that he had resigned veterans Gary Roberts and Mark Recchi to one-year contracts. Neither contract is outlandish, and more importantly than just monetary factors, Roberts and Recchi provide a veteran presence sorely necessary, both on and off the ice, for a very young team.

What Recchi and Roberts bring off the ice is not disputed. Even as Pens' fans joke about Mark Recchi's usefulness as Jordan Staal's landlord, the fans understand that it's necessary for younger players to have a few older players around off the ice. And not just because some of the youngest Penguins literally need a billet house with an older teammate (which will be even more true next year if Kris Letang and, though it's unlikely, Angelo Esposito, make the team). Rather, Roberts and Recchi bring a wealth of experience to such things as travel, conditioning, eating properly, etc., to the team. Roberts and Recchi have won Cups, and say what you will, but most teams don't win Cups until they have players who have helped to teach them what it takes to win a Cup. Off the ice, Roberts and Recchi bring stability and experience to a young, talented team that could tremendously benefit from stable, experienced veteran leadership.

Roberts and Recchi aren't just useful as the "veterans in the locker room," but are likewise tremendously valuable on the ice--but not for the reasons one might at first assume. Gary Roberts and Mark Recchi are both valuable on the ice because, at this juncture of their careers, they are both no-maintenance players. By no-maintenance, I do not mean that they can play 30 minutes a game without problem, but that in the minutes they do play within a game, they are going to know what to do and how to do it. Fans already love Gary Roberts and know that he knows when to dish a thundering check that changes the momentum of a shift and a game. While fans are more likely to complain about Recchi, Recchi's "no maintenance" value is probably best seen in Game 4 of the Pittsburgh-Ottawa first round series. No coach had to tell Recchi to use those old legs and race back to keep the puck from going into the empty net; no coach had to tell him how to do it. In small plays that win and lose games, in the simple plays that talented kids sometimes haven't yet been forced to master, Mark Recchi and Gary Roberts both exemplify what it means to be a "no-maintenance" hockey player. And, in demonstrating what it means to be a "no maintenance" player, Recchi and Roberts will help the Pens' obscenely talented youth begin to develop, also, into players who wear the label "no-maintenance."

For all the on and off-ice good that Roberts and Recchi bring, I must return to a post that I wrote late in the 2006-07 season (called "The Veteran Myth"). The "veteran myth" states that players like Roberts and Recchi, because they have always fulfilled certain roles quite well, must continue to be relied upon to fill those same roles based upon their experience in said capacity. My current opinion remains the same one I held when I first typed out "The Veteran Myth." And that opinion is that Coach Michel Therrien and his coaching staff must not allow veteran players who have "always done that" to continue to do a job that could be better performed by a younger but more inexperienced player.

The power play unit for next season would provide an easy example of "The Veteran Myth." Sticking both Mark Recchi and Gary Roberts on the first team power play unit would be a mistake of monumental proportions. Not allowing all six feet four inches of Jordan Staal to have some time in front of the crease on the power play due to the "experience" of Roberts and Recchi is not just incredibly shortsighted, but fundamentally wrong. Young players need the chance to master a specific skill set, and young players can do this while still helping their teams to win games. The challenge for the coaching staff will be to monitor the playing time of the Pens' graybeards, to use them wisely, but not to overuse them--and not just to prevent injury and burnout, but to allow the kids, the kids who have to play starring roles when it comes to time to compete for the Cup, to begin the process of assuming such starring roles.

For the wealth of on-ice and off-ice experience and leadership that Roberts and Recchi bring to the Pens, for the fact that both wanted to remain with the kids, I welcome them back with open arms, clapping hands, and lots of loud cheers. However, Penguins' general manager Ray Shero needs to work in conjunction with Michel Therrien and his coaching staff to ensure that the veterans and the kids are utilized properly--and that might mean, perhaps more far more frequently than in the 2006-07 season--that a few of the kids start to do some of the things, such as, for example, stand in front of the net on the power play, a little more often than do the veterans.
Angelo Esposito is Not Jordan Staal But....

Okay. I'll admit it. It was nice to go back to rooting for my Pens. And by this, of course, I mean, rooting for the precipitious falls of 2 talented teenage prospects, both of whom, for a variety of reasons, were ultimately drafted lower than where they were projected to be drafted.

Had I been live-blogging the draft, my in-the-moment thoughts would have been something like, "Drop, drop, drop, drop, drop," and "Please don't pick the players they keep showing on the TV." While I had a feeling the Rangers wouldn't let a talented Russian scare them off, I was still hoping that a natural wing, and a goal scorer, to boot, would be available for my Pens to snatch at 20. Alas, Cherepanov is now property of the New York Rangers, may have the chance to play on the same team as his idol, and Penguins' fans are spared another Evgeni-Malkinesque escape-from-Russia saga. (Not that I would have objected to the saga considering the talent of the player in question.)

To resume the thoughts of my live-blogging that wasn't, after the Rangers snagged Cherepanov, it was just countdown until number twenty. Since the TSN cameras would not leave Angelo Esposito alone, well, neither could I. At least not in my mind. My absolutely articulate thoughts of "Drop, drop, drop!" continued even as I watched other players get picked, even as I knew that Esposito was not a Brian Burke-type player. And then the announcers who asked, "Could he be lucky enough to have Pittsburgh take him?" And, of course, what I later read about how the team searched frantically for nameplate but didn't have one. But who really cared about a nameplate when your team gets a player at 20 that they had expected to go much higher? Really, I was too delighted to care. I had rooted for something to happen, for my team to "win," so to speak, the chance to draft Esposito, and they had. That was nice.

After my excitement at snagging a player whose talent had him ranked as the consensus #1 overall pick just a year ago, I began to wonder about Esposito. How had he fallen from a consensus first overall pick to being available for the Penguins to grab in the 20th spot? And more than just wondering about Esposito's "freefall," I wondered what it might be reasonable to expect of him. And thus began the googling, which led to a few conclusions, which are summarized by the title of this post.

Angelo Esposito is not Jordan Staal. Angelo Esposito is not Jordan Staal. Repeat. Nor is Angelo Esposito Evgeni Malkin. Angelo Esposito is certainly not Sidney Crosby, a player to whom he was once, ridiculously, ludicrously, outlandishly, and too early compared. No. Angelo Esposito is Angelo Esposito, and that means, well--what does that mean?

Before dealing with Esposito, let's deal with the people who heaped unrealistic and some would say absurd expectations upon the kid. He spent his rookie year in the Q playing with another player who starred in the Q. He was the Q's Rookie of the Year and won the Memorial Cup as a rookie. Not too shabby a debut. And at this point, the hoopla started. Ridiculous hoopla. Esposito this, Esposito that. He was a talented kid, a year (ONE year) removed from playing high school prep hockey, but suddenly he was supposed to be the second coming of Sidney Crosby (a once-in-a-GENERATION-talent). And not only that, he was supposed to be the best player on the defending Memorial Cup champions, a team that was supposed to stay great no matter the loss of talented players to the ranks of the NHL teams that drafted them. Worse than that, probably, this kid played on a team coached by Patrick Roy. While Roy is one of the best goalies in NHL history, to say that he is fiery and eccentric would be a vast understatement. Playing under Roy is going to be a challenge any day of the week, no matter his legitimately great NHL playing experience.

And then came this season. And the scouts poked holes wherever they could find holes. It wasn't like Esposito wasn't helping them out--he got cut from Canada's World Junior team. He didn't put up the stats he'd put up in his rookie season. He couldn't carry his team on his own. And his team got booted in the first round of the playoffs. And those "questions" surrounded him. Was he too soft? Could he carry a team on his own? Was he too selfish? Did he use his linemates well enough?

Before going into more detail about what might be reasonably expected of Esposito, let's talk about reasonable expectations for the team, media, and fans. Let's not make the same mistake everyone did a year ago when they began to heap ridiculous, absurd expectations upon Esposito. Let's make sure not to make that mistake. And let's consider what some of our unreasonable expectations might be.


Unreasonable Expectation/Comparison 1:Sidney Crosby played and starred in the NHL at age eighteen. So if Sidney could do it....

Counterpoint: No, no, and can I say a very emphatic NO just one more time? Sidney Crosby also broke Mario Lemieux's rookie points scoring record. Esposito is surely not going to do that.


Unreasonable Expectation/Comparison 2: While Esposito might not be ready now, he might be ready to do in two years something like what Malkin did this year.

Counterpoint: No, no, and no. Malkin spent time playing in the Russian Elite League against men. Sure, Malkin had (and still must continue) to adjust his game and learn the English language. But the Russian Elite League could very well be the second best hockey league in the entire world. Being trained while playing against men is very different than playing against boys in the QMJHL.


Unreasonable Expectation/Comparison 3: Nobody really expected Jordan Staal to do what he did last year. And while Staal wasn't Crosby, or even as offensively flashy as Malkin, he still stepped in as an eighteen-year-old and took a regular shift. Why couldn't we expect Esposito to "surprise" us and do something similar?

Counterpoint: Jordan Staal was already six foot four and two hundred twenty pounds. Despite his age, Staal's precocious physical development was definitely a factor that enabled him to transition easily to the NHL game. Likewise, Staal had been utilized the previous year by Peterborough Petes' coach Dick Todd primarily in a defensive role--in other words, part of the reason Staal had such a phenomenal rookie season was due to his on-ice defensive awareness.


Of all the unreasonable expectations that could be foisted upon on Esposito by the organization, the media, and the fans, it's perhaps the comparison to Staal that concerns me the most. The organization surely knows how exceptional Crosby is and how Malkin is still a world-class talent. The media and fans, when they're minding their manners and using common sense, likewise seem aware that Crosby is unique and Malkin is slightly less special than Crosby. The most dangerous viewpoint, for the organization, fans, and media, seems to be expecting that Esposito could be able to transition the way Staal did.

Two things about Esposito must be noted, neither of which, necessarily, are anything that time and development can't heal. Esposito is six foot one and a hundred and eighty pounds. In other words, weight-wise, he's small for the NHL at the moment. He needs to fill out and add muscle mass, hardly an incurable problem, but not one necessarily solved in a summer's time. Secondly, Jordan Staal played for the Peterborough Petes under legendary coach Dick Todd. Dick Todd knew how to coach and develop junior players. Patrick Roy has proved he is one of the finest NHL goalies in NHL history, but he has yet to prove anything in terms of DEVELOPING (not just coaching) junior players. Staal had the benefit of excellent and experienced junior coaching and precocious physical development, and both benefits were major factors as to why Staal was able to end the 2006-07 season as a Rookie-of-the-Year candidate. Let me repeat, once again, that Angelo Esposito is NOT Jordan Staal. Esposito had the chance to play under a NHL Hall-of-Famer, but not an expert and seasoned junior coach. And as far as physical development goes, Esposito's weight has yet to fill out to match his height, at least by NHL standards--and Jordan Staal was already among the biggest men in the league last season.

Perhaps because of the heavy expectations and labels that burdened Esposito for the past year, I am leery of expecting him to stick for the 2007-08 season. I am leery that the Pens' organization might erreneously believe that another talented 18-year-old with the potential to be a star one day could step right in and skate a regular shift at age 18. Though for the most part I trust Ray Shero (until he proves he should not deserve my trust), I'm more frightened still for the expectations that might be heaped upon Esposito by the media and the Pittsburgh fanbase. If the Pens' think they just found Sidney Crosby a winger, and Esposito sticks but scores 11 goals and 15 assists while playing on the third and fourth lines, well, how is he going to compare to the rookie sensations fans and the media have grown accustomed to over the past couple of seasons?

Now, of course, Shero is right when he says that coming to Pittsburgh might be the perfect place for Esposito. He can skate like the wind, play with lots of young, talented players, and never have to be "the guy" on his team. And, to some degree, if the team is successful, and Esposito shows development as a player, well, the fact that he's probably not going to be another Pittsburgh Calder Trophy nominee will just have to be something fans and the media get over.

So, to summarize a lengthy, rambling post: Esposito should not be expected to make the team next season. At this juncture, provided he's not ridiculously out of his league, I see no harm in a few-game NHL cup of coffee, at the start of the season, provided he will help the team win games (which must be a consideration with a team now expected to make the playoffs). I agree with fans who've stated that they'd like to see Esposito spend as much time as possible with Crosby, Roberts, et. al to adjust whatever real or imagined "issues" he may have. Frankly speaking, I'd rather have him spend as much time as possible with Coach Michel Therrien rather than Coach Patrick Roy (but that's another post for another time, perhaps to be expanded upon later in the long, summer months). But if Esposito comes to camp and isn't ready, well, don't freak out. He's eighteen, a kid, and eighteen-year-olds, save for ones not named Crosby, Jordan Staal, and Jaromir Jagr, tend to need a few more years before they're NHL-ready.

But the thing that had Ray Shero, other fans, and me, screaming in our heads such inarticulate nonsense as "Drop, drop, drop, to us, please!" is that Esposito, like Crosby, Malkin, and Staal before him, shares the trait that you look for when you draft. It's called "upside." Had the Pens been picking closer to the top of the draft, they would have had more than "one short" interview with Esposito. They might have learned what caused other teams to back off, or they might have learned about his upside. And, drafting at 20, you have to go with upside.

And that's the exciting thing. A part of me seriously hopes Esposito can stick in the NHL next year because it's always fun when scary young talent gets joined by still younger talent (and also because I'd rather have Esposito a part of the Pens' team than spend another year with his QMJHL team and coach, but again, another topic for another time). Another part of me hopes that if the kid, as is true of most-eighteen-year-olds, just isn't ready, that the organization does what's best for him. I hope the organization can wait a few years before, perhaps, he can play a supporting role on a team that, by then, should be a legitimate Cup contender.

But let's cut the kid a break, and ourselves a break, too. He's not Crosby. He's not Malkin. He's not Staal. And we don't want him to be. We've already got Crosby, Malkin, and Staal. What Pens should want is for Angelo Esposito to be Angelo Esposito....and let's wait and see what his "upside" ultimately becomes without ridiculously comparing him to the three out-of-this-world rookies we've been blessed to watch in the span of the past two years.

And if Esposito shocks me, the way Jordan Staal shocked most of us last season, well and good, fair and square, who's going to complain? Only the teams who passed on drafting him.

But, in the more likely scenario that when we watch Esposito, we see flaws or traits that caused him to drop in his draft year (almost a reverse of how Jordan Staal ascended in his draft class), let's just enjoy continuing to watch a Calder Trophy winner and 2 Calder Trophy nominees (one of whom, not incidentally, now has a Hart, Art Ross, and Pearson) without freaking out if our 20th overall pick isn't yet ready to be a Calder Trophy nominee at age 18, 19, or even 20. Let Angelo Esposito be Angelo Esposito, and let's see what happens.
Winners and Losers of the 2007 NHL Draft?

Ask Me in Five--No, Ten--Years

I have always loved the NHL draft. I love to watch the smiles, hugs, and handshakes as teenagers, if only momentarily, realize a lifelong dream. In particular, the first round of the NHL draft is typically great theater. In creative writing terms, there are several dramatic questions to be answered. "Who will go first overall?" "Will there be trades?" "Where will this often injured/fast-rising/falling prospect go?"

Yet the real dramatic question of the NHL draft--"Which of these teenagers will turn into legitimate NHL stars/supporting players/role players?"--is one that cannot, honestly, be accurately assessed until several years after that draft. Which is one of the reasons I absolutely refuse to participate in the whole punditry/blogging/etc. game of assessing the "winners and losers" of a particular entry draft. Because, generally speaking, unless you're drafting a Mario Lemieux, Sidney Crosby, or other once-in-a-generation talent or minimally a franchise talent, you cannot accurately say that you have "won" or "lost" anything. Not yet. Not now.

Now, of course, others would beg to dispute this point with me. For example, Pierre McGuire will insist that the Rangers got a steal at the seventeenth overall pick. Well, maybe, the kid who idolized Jagr is going to end up being a kid who can ultimately replace Jags as the centerpiece of the Rangers. (Though, as an aside, I'd beg Jags not to hang up his skates too soon; I still enjoy watching him play.) Or maybe that kid's not going to be able to replace Jagr but will serve as a wonderful supporting player. Perhaps the kid might have difficulty adjusting to the culture of North America or to the American ice rinks for a few years and not begin to hit his professional stride until he's in his mid-twenties. And, while of course no one wishes this for any player, there's a possibility that something horrible happens when that kid, or any of the kids drafted this year, plays next season, and some type of injury prevents them from becoming a NHL player.

My point in the above paragraph, which could just as easily be applied to the Penguins' pick of Angelo Esposito, is that no one knows. Not really. Not yet. In the cases of Mario, Crosby, and a few others, okay, everyone knows. In other cases, however, well, it takes time. While often it only takes five years to determine that the college kid you took a chance on in a later round is never going to play in the NHL, when it comes to certain other players, I'd rather wait ten years, not five, to evaluate a draft. And as a fan and not a professional scout or general manager, I have this luxury.

Let's examine the case of 2 former Penguins, both Europeans, both the captains of their respective teams.

Case 1: Jaromir Jagr: He was drafted fifth overall in 1990.

Five Years After His Draft Year: He's won his first league scoring title in the lockout-shortened season by scoring more goals than Eric Lindros. We know he's good, but he hasn't quite yet ascended to the level of best hockey player on the planet.

Ten Years After His Draft Year: He's won multiple league scoring championships as well as captured the Pearson and the Hart. He's become the best hockey player in the world, and Craig Patrick, along with Pens' fans, are grateful that four other teams passed on the "risk" that was an eighteen-year-old Jaromir Jagr in the 1990 entry draft.


Case 2: Markus Naslund: He was drafted sixteenth overall in 1991.

Five Years After His Draft Year: Despite obvious talent, Naslund has shown only flashes of scoring ability in the NHL. On March 20, 1996, Craig Patrick trades Naslund to Vancouver for another underachieving former first-round draft pick.

Ten Years After His Draft Year: Maturity and a new setting eventually help Naslund to become the player he was drafted to become. He is the captain of his team and a NHL All-Star.


Examining the cases of Jagr and Naslund--both of whom, whether Pens' fans like it or not, have succeeded as NHL stars at various points in their respective careers--reveals that evaluating a player only five years after his draft year makes for an incomplete evaluation. In the case of Naslund, who fits the moniker "late bloomer" too perfectly, it was twelve years after his draft year when he was voted the NHL's best player by a jury of his peers and won the Pearson Trophy. If you'd judged Jagr after five years, you would have said, "Great pick." If you had judged Naslund after five years, you would have been attempted, as many Pittsburgh hockey fans did at the time, to say, "Bust." But you wouldn't have known just how "great" Jaromir Jagr would become, and you surely never would have anticipated that a player who also initially struggled in Vancouver would become a NHL captain and 1st Team NHL All Star. Which just goes to show you that if it's a stretch to evaluate a draft five years after the fact and that you can still have things to learn ten years after the draft--how utterly silly it is to compose a list of "winners and losers" the day after the draft ends. Let's wait until these children play a NHL game or two, all right, before we start labeling teams as "winners" or "losers," okay?

Of course, NHL general managers and scouting staffs do not have the luxury that I have. In order to evaluate their own draft performance, general managers and scouting teams have to assess their team's draft performance year after year after year. They don't get to say, 10 years later, Oh, we learned from that correct projection and that incorrect projection. They have to evaluate and evaluate and evaluate, and for them, it's a much shorter cycle.

All that being said, of course, unless a team is clearing the last hurdles it needs to capture a Cup, it's silly to hemorrhage assets (e.g. draft picks). In the days that immediately follow a draft, shortsighted quick fixes where draft picks are sacrificed and that ultimately don't move a team into the category of legitimate Cup contender, well, okay, those teams can be called "draft day losers." Minimally, they lost out on adding organizational depth, but perhaps they lost out on a future star. So I'll maintain those short-sighted quick fixes that fail to catapult a team to Cup contender, honestly, are a waste that can result in the short-term label of draft day losers and perhaps longer term label of still losers.

But since I'm not a general manager or a scout, let's be honest and let's be real. The time to ask me about who won and who lost in this draft is going to be, minimally, in 5 years, save for the exceptional, precocious cases of a player or two. And better still, ask me in 10 years.

Except you won't have to ask me. Or anyone else. Because everyone will know. Because we'll know which prospects turned into players.

That's what makes me tune into the NHL draft every summer (aside from being in desperate need of a hockey fix while suffering through another interminable season of losing Pirates baseball). It's fun to remember the kids as prospects and watch those NHL prospects morph into NHL players. It's more fun still because we don't know what will be yet, and somehow, the unknown is always a bit more exciting than what we know.





Wednesday, June 06, 2007

3rd Period Live-Blogging

As I eat my dinner, I watch Mike Fisher go after the puck like a madman. If only the rest of the Senators could match that all-out effort and desire.

The unfortunate 3rd goal aside, Chris Phillips is still a solid defenseman. His stick breaks, and rather than taking a penalty, he uses his skate and kicks the puck to another Senator. Solid play by a solid player. If only the Senators could get more of that...eh, I don't want the Senators to win, so let's forget that.

Scott Niedermayer for MVP. Niedermayer's shot on net results in another Anaheim goal. 5-2 Anaheim. I do like a three goal lead. I would like a four goal lead better, and a five goal lead better still, and well, you get the idea.

Songs of "Emery, Emery," resound, followed by "We want the Cup! We want the Cup!" Have I mentioned how much I LOVE playoff hockey?

Oh, and prior to the start of the period, the Cup is finally in the building. I don't get to see it yet; it's still inside the case. But the Cup is here. Edzo is talking about where he took the Cup.

The current Anaheim PP aside, waiting for time to tick down when you're in Anaheim's position is.....time lags, every second feels much longer than it is, and--

Penalty Shot! For Ottawa! Still playoff hockey....Jiggy says no. Mike Emerick tells us the Sens still trail by 3.

From my own limited perspective, penalty shots matter. Jaromir Jagr scores on a penalty shot against the Rangers in 1992 was one of the goals that helped the Pens to win a tight game when Mario Lemieux was out with a broken wrist. Ken Wregget had to stop a penalty shot in the "pajama game" of the Pens-Washington game back in 1996. The game wouldn't end with the penalty shot in the 2nd OT; that had to wait until the fourth OT. On the flip side of the coin, Aleksey Morozov failed to score on a penalty shot against the Montreal Canadians. The Pens lost the game, the series, and Morozov. While blaming Morozov's entire North American underachievement on that one unconverted penalty shot is a bit much, that penalty shot made a big difference for the game, the series, and the player. Anyhow, unfortunately for Ottawa, this penalty shot goes to Anaheim, not to them as a "series turning point."


The "We want the Cup" chant starts again, and I concur. Keep playing your game, Anaheim, and watch the seconds tick off the clock...

Memory: My ninth birthday was two days before the Pens won their first Cup. In my third grade naivete, I assumed that all Cup victories would be as lopsided as that 8-0 victory was. As soon as the Pens had put up a couple of goals, the rest of the game felt like a ridiculously long wait. A wait for the Cup. A wait for dreams come true. Ah, the memories.

Clock Check: Seven minutes and thirty three seconds left, and a Senator goes to the penalty box.

Crushing a team's will to win? The Ducks are very, very good, but no team in the Cup Finals should have their will to win crushed. C'mon, you're playing for the Cup. (Note: Yes, I realize it's unlikely, but those tried and true cliches are tried and true for a reason. You play as hard as you can, to the best of your ability, until the buzzer sounds.)

Mike Fisher reference #1,789 (that's what it feels like, anyhow): Either these commentators really like Fisher, like me, or they're seeing what Murray and I are seeing. (Inside my Head Commentary: How in the world are Murray and I seeing the same thing?) Murray comes to his senses and decides to double-shift his best player. Unfortunately for a team with Dany Heatley, Jason Spezza, and Daniel Alfredsson, Mike Fisher has been Ottawa's best player this game and this series.

Memo to Self: I really hope Evgeni Malkin's somewhat lackluster play this postseason was the result of fatigue and needing to adjust to the North American game. This postseason, Sidney Crosby and Jordan Staal weren't as good as they one day will be. But I hope Malkin's issues are ones of needing to adjust and get experience rather than....well....I don't even want to say it yet because it's not fair to put a certain onus on a player as young and inexperienced as Malkin. Draw your own inference.

It's not official yet, but it is: Justice. Alfredsson's pass goes astray, and Perry scores. 6-2 Anaheim with less than 3 minutes to go.

Countdown to the end: The stories come now, and begin by Emerick talking about the joy and sadness that both happen when championship games are won--or lost. The great jubilation of the champions contrasted to the stark sorrow of the team who finished second best. They talk first about the Senators taking pride in a terrific season--true, but how empty that feels at this moment. And now about Randy Carlyle, who played for so many not-so-good (understatement) Pittsburgh teams, finally winning the Cup. And Teemu Selanne, perhaps, possibly, retiring as a champion.

Less than a minute to go. Time to watch the greatest prize in sports get awarded. And enjoy as much of the show as NBC TV will permit me to see.
2nd Intermission Live Blogging

Caveat: While impertinent to readers, I have yet to eat dinner, and I live on the East Coast. Sigh. What playoff hockey does to me. In any case, blogging might not be as frequent.

The Bozos and I agree: On the fact that the line of Schaeffer-Alfredsson-Fisher was the most effective one in the 2nd period. And for all Alfredsson scored that shorthanded goal, I'd take Mike Fisher over Alfredsson any day of the week if I'm a GM who's tasked to build a Cup winner. You need guys like Fisher to win a Cup.

Sigh: This agreeing with the Bozos thing has got to stop. I wasn't listening all that closely to the Bozos' recap of the 2nd period, but I agreed with the basic idea that the Ducks need to keep forechecking and not sit back on a lead and that Ottawa should roll out that Fisher-Alfredsson combo as much as possible. Still, that's scary. But if the 2006-07 season officially concludes tonight, I'll have a whole lot of time next year to go back to disagreeing with the Bozos.

Commercials: Seriously, could they get better commercials for the playoffs? I usually mute commercials, but blogging precludes fussing with the mute button as I usually do. Snark warning: Oh, never mind about the commercials. I just remembered the NHL has a "contract" with NBC that's made me concerned about just how much of the Cup being awarded I'll actually be able to see. Sigh.

Time to Eat. Seriously.

2nd Period Live Blogging

Perhaps to follow up on my 1st intermission post, the announcing team starts heaping praise on Mike Fisher. They praise Fisher for such ordinary things, such to-be-expected-from-leaders things as giving his all and knowing he won't "mail it in". Newsflash for Ottawa: What Fisher shows is called character. Regardless of the fact that a C is not stitched on his chest, you might want to emulate his example if you don't want to watch another team win the Cup this evening.

Teemu Selanne leaves the penalty box. And, for a few minutes, the officials decide to take a break from seeing if they can give Ottawa a chance to get back in the game. A less cynical perspective, or less biased, depending on your own point of view, would say that the Ducks don't take penalties for a few minutes.

The Ducks are getting chances, but have yet to score. Pierre thinks Murray should take a timeout to settle down the Senators. I don't expect Murray to take Pierre's advice. Memo to Ottawa: Finding the character to believe in yourselves and play effectively in the face of a bigger, stronger opponent might be helpful. (Not that I should be providing help to Ottawa.)

Musing: I've always enjoyed the Sounds of the Game segment (partially because usually the tickets that close to the ice were always too expensive for me to purchase). But sometimes I wonder if the NHL should somehow make arrangements to "bleep out" the sometimes colorful language used by players in the midst of exchanges that are enlightening, informative, and entertaining. Let's be honest: Hockey players sometimes use certain language as par for the course. Rather than only give us tidbits of sounds, give us the real stuff. Bleeped out, of course, and nothing too ridiculous. But give us the trash talk and the challenges. Not only does it entertain, it does get fans "inside" the game.

Growl: Just as I'm about to say that if I'm Anaheim, I hate the idea of Daniel Alfredsson playing with Mike Fisher, Alfredsson puts the puck behind Jiggy. Apparently character playing with talent can help talent perform as talent should. But really, who should be wearing the captain's C for Ottawa? And what does it say that Mike Fisher, who I've come to respect but who is not an out-of-this-world offensive talent, is really the best player on the ice? There's something wrong with the Senators, but it's not Mike Fisher.

Tit for Tat: Pierre and Edzo have been bickering throughout the second period. More so than Emerick has been calling the game. More on Pierre and Edzo later. If I feel like it. I might not. They're still nowhere near as laugh-aloud hysterical as were FSN guys Steigy and Errey this year, though.

Wow: Just as things had been turning around for Ottawa, and momentum had swung their way, and it was the Ducks standing still, according to Pierre (I agreed, but I hate saying that), Chris Phillips, pressured by Rob Niedermayer, puts a puck behind Ray Emery. It's a bad luck goal, but luck matters. And momentum shifts.

More Wow: Phillips is another one of those solid character people the Senators actually have (unfortunately two of their star players don't appear to have this--more on that in a second). But the look on his face, the defeated look, the "I can't believe that happened," portends another facial expression, and that's a facial expression of disbelief, one of, "I can't believe we can come back." The Ducks are much better equipped to deal with the Senators than were any of the Eastern playoff teams.

Momentum is a Fragile Thing: Getzlaf loses the puck on the PP, and Alfredsson scores shorthanded. I will never root for Daniel Alfredsson. Amazingly, I think Alfredsson scored without Fisher on the ice with him. Wow.

Momentum is a Fragile Thing, Part 2: In the thirty seconds it took to type the previous sentences (yes, I type fast), Beauchemin scores. Anaheim converts on the PP and has a 2 goal lead once more. Beautiful.

Getzlaf/Carlyle versus Spezza/Murray: Missing person jokes are circulating around the Internet about where Jason Spezza has been throughout the Finals. This period, Pierre informed the viewing audience that Murray was screaming at Spezza and Spezza was screaming right back at his coach. While Murray is right to call out Spezza for certain plays, it's worth remembering Spezza's a kid (not a child, like the Pens' teenagers). Murray needs to do what good coaches do: do whatever's necessary to give a talented kid the chance to succeed. And yes, that means calling Spezza out, screaming if necessary--but it also means, well, things should have taken place before screaming and things should take place after screaming. Those things are called adjustments. Adjustments to a different line or to missing a shift or just to teaching a kid how to play an opponent who plays a style the kid's totally unaccustomed to seeing.

Speaking of kids like Spezza, Ryan Getzlaf is also a kid. Pierre didn't bring us a report about what Carlyle said when Getzlaf got "too cute" and Alfredsson scored, but I wondered. Getzlaf's been called out for taking "stupid" penalties, and perhaps if he had taken a penalty there, Alfredsson doesn't score. I wondered what Carlyle said and how he said it. Because there's a time and a place for call-outs, rebuking, and screaming. But if you're a good coach, a coach who wants to coach a champion, you know you need your best players, even if they're just kids, to be your best players. Say this for the coaches, and I'm not making judgments of the players here: Carlyle has done more with Getzlaf, and gotten more from him, way more, than Murray has with Spezza. And when it comes to kids, that's not just a reflection on the players. It's a reflection on the coaches.

End of Period. 4-2 Anaheim. When do I get to see a picture of the Stanley Cup? Where is the Cup in the building?
Live Blogging -- 1st Intermission

Bozo Ray says the Sens were "brutal." Bozo Brett borrows what he said about the Ducks back on May 20th and says the Sens are terrible, horrible, etc, everywhere.
Note: I loved the flashback to what Bozo Brett said in pregame. That's a nice segment. It adds an entertaining element that's sorely necessary when the Bozos are using such advanced hockey vocabulary as "brutal" and "terrible."


My own analysis: Granted, since I'm not into the rhetoric of certainty, I'm aware that everything I type now could come back and be proved untrue. And yet, well, here it is.

Ottawa was nervous and uptight and not desperate enough in the 1st period. As the Bozos helpfully point out, Murray screaming at the refs just might not be the best way to approach them (even though Ottawa is Canada's capital). But it wasn't just Murray. It was most of the Senators. The big line still hasn't clicked five-on-five for the Sens.

Facing a team replete not just with character, but experienced character, I can't help but wonder, yet again, about Daniel Alfredsson--and particularly about that shot at Scott Niedermayer. Say what you will, but I'm not sure Fisher's answer of "It's everybody" they have to look to is the one a Senators fan should want the team to have. Sure, you want everyone to do their part. But you want your leaders to lead. Unfortunately for the Sens, Daniel Alfredsson showed his "leadership skill" in the waning seconds of the second period of Game 4. The Sens would be better off with a different captain, with a player of whom I could say--the way I say of Scott Niedermayer--"don't boo that guy, he screams class."

In any case, if the Sens don't win this game, it's in large part not just because their best players were beaten by Anaheim's best players but because the character of their best players, or lack thereof, showed out in a negative way.

Just for clarification: I'm not saying every Senators "star" lacks character. I'm not overgeneralizing about the whole of the team. But imagine yourself (I know it's hard) in the shoes of a Senator's fan: Which player on your team has the combination of skill and character that would inspire you to belief? That would inspire his teammates to do their jobs? Perhaps, at some point in the future, it's time for the Senators to find someone, or appoint someone, who can give to the Sens the kind of leadership that Scott Niedermayer has given to the Ducks. (And I'm not talking multiple-Cup wins here. Just old fashioned leadership, the same kind old school guys who hadn't won the Cup to that point--e.g. Bourque, etc.--gave to their teams.)
PERIOD 1 LIVE-BLOGGING

  • Ottawa is trying to pull what they pulled in Game 5 of their 1st round playoff series. The Senators are giving Anaheim a chance to win this game in the 1st period. The Senators are the ones taking penalties, and--

  • Anaheim is better than the Pittsburgh Penguins. (I also feel the need to note that the Ducks, at least in terms of their blueline, are not just more skilled, but more experienced.) The Ducks score a power play goal to take a 1-0 lead. A Deep Sigh: Oh, what would have been if the Pens had been able to score on one of those power play opportunities early in Game 5 in the 1st round. Oh, the lessons the children hopefully learned. At least the Ducks have already won the same number of games against the Sens as three of the East's best teams combined to win.

  • Another Ottawa penalty, but this time, Ottawa kills the penalty. And Chris Pronger, after being hit, is missed. The announcing team analyzes Pronger's absence in detail. The Ducks' PP is out of sync, and Ottawa is breathing slightly easier. A little later, we're informed the equipment trainer is still on the bench, so the inference is made, "it's gotta be medical." My own analysis: Pronger potentially getting injured and leaving the game is one of those things that can happen in hockey games that the pregame Bozos did not account for in their "rhetoric of certainty" guarantee that the Ducks would end the night by lifting the Cup. Further analysis: Pronger's planned absence (e.g. when suspended) is actually easier for the Ducks to deal with--you have a defenseman who's dressed in his place. Going down a defenseman is never easy, and going down a defenseman like Pronger, when you're not physically (another dressed D) or mentally (PP without Pronger) to deal with his absence, could potentially influence who wins this game.

  • I agree with Edzo that Scott Niedermayer is great. But I plead with Edzo, please, no, no, no, absolutely no rhyming to tell me how great Niedermayer is. Further Note: Note only does Niedermayer up his game with Pronger out, play solid defense, carry the puck, and dish off effective passes (all in the span of a shift), but he is my Conn Smythe winner at this point. Not merely for his play, but for his maturity and sanity in reminding his team, before the third period of Game 4, that they needed to win the game and not focus on Danny Alfredsson being a punk.

  • The Anaheim fans show they watched Game 4 in Ottawa. The Anaheim faithful loudly and beautifully boo Alfredsson every time he touches the puck. I would say Anaheim fans are giving the Senators captain the "Sidney Crosby" treatment, but Daniel Alfredsson should never again be mentioned in the same breath or sentence as Sidney Crosby. (It's impertinent at this point that the Sens beat the Pens in Round 1. Crosby at 19 has more of a clue of how to lead and be a captain than Alfredsson has at 34.) Alfredsson has now gotten into the same "borderline dirty" category as Chris Pronger with that ridiculous shot at Niedermayer, that did, as one of the Bozos noted, ruin his previously pretty much "squeaky clean" persona. And unlike Crosby or Pronger, Alfredsson doesn't necessarily seem like one who'd know to respond to the booing. Further Note: Unlike the way the Ottawa fans booed Niedermayer, I have no qualms with--I actually ENCOURAGE--the Ducks' faithful flock to continue to boo Alfredsson as long and hard and loud as possible.

  • Chris Pronger returns to the bench, and the fans applaud. Pierre informs us, again, that in case we couldn't tell from his utter lack of boneheaded plays and consistently strong play, that Mike Fisher is smart. The Ottawa players, of course, turned to see why the fans were applauding, and Pierre diagnoses what Fisher's beautiful (sorry, I am still a female) eyes reveal. The Sens are up against that much more with Pronger back--not just on the bench, but on the ice.

  • The Sens are up against way more now. Though the officials are doing their best to give the Sens a chance to get back in this game, Ottawa's not very receptive to the idea of converting on power plays. As an Ottawa PP ends, Rob Niedermayer scores. Beautiful. Anaheim is up 2-0.

  • the period ends. While the crowd roars approval of the 2-0 lead, Pierre talks to Mike Fisher. Even though Fisher somehow manages to spout off every hockey cliche in the book (the whole team thing, give it everything they have, etc) in less than a minute, I don't roll my eyes. I can't help it. I'm like Mike Emerick, who appreciates that Fisher is available for interviews at the end of the period. And I can't help but think that if Ottawa's captain had the character of Mike Fisher, the Ottawa Senators would have a much better chance to win the Cup.

Game 5 Live-Blogging

PREGAME

Ah, the beautiful pregame introduction. Emerick narrates and tells me about Ducks fans who have taken the day off work in anticipation of the Cup Finals. Snark: Well, with a 5 p.m. start time, no wonder Ducks fans have to take the day off work. Musing: How much fun will it be for me to take the day off work, with a SPECIFIC PURPOSE in mind (rather than just I felt like it) when MY team is 60 minutes away from the Cup?

Speaking of being 60 minutes away from the Cup, Bill asks Bozo 1 and Bozo 2 if the Ducks that burning question. Both Bozos answer the question in the affirmative: the Ducks will win this game. My own musing: I hate what I once heard termed (in college, yes) "the rhetoric of certainty." Can't we just ENJOY the game without hearing guarantees? Unless those guarantees are going to come from the people who actually decide the game, of course (snark: which hopefully will be the PLAYERS and not the officials).

Pierre asks Danny Alfredsson about shooting that puck at Scott Niedermayer. Danny Alfredsson's answer reveals that he has a future career as a politician somewhere as he claims his shot wasn't deliberate. More frightening than Alfredsson revealing that he has the weasel characteristics that make a politician is the fact that I agree with both Bozos. Brett Hull is right on the money when he says, "Does anyone believe that?" and Ferraro makes the point that 40 goal scorers generally have control over where they shoot the puck. I mean, say what you will for Alfredsson, but a general inability to take accurate shots will not be found in any scouting report of the Ottawa captain.

Pierre talks to Chris Pronger pregame. We all know Chris Pronger is a huge behemoth, but the way Pierre is staring up at him, it really looks like Pierre is purring in his ear. And if one wants to talk about "media bias," well, I think Pierre really does have some affection for Chris Pronger. Not that it matters when it comes to coverage of a hockey game, even the deciding game of the SCF, but Pierre's tone with Prongs was different than his tone with Alfredsson. But then, you know, Pierre once coached Pronger. It's nice for a coach to hope for a former player to succeed. Too bad Murray can't hope for the players he drafted to succeed. Actually, considering it's Murray, it's not bad at all.

A brief tidbit about Ryan Getzlaf, including how Randly Carlyle "rides" him--and "rides" him appears to mean uses him in all situations rather than, you know, "rides" him the way Carlyle has done throughout the year, such as when Getzlaf gets named the game's #1 star and Carlyle still proclaims everything in his game that could and should be improved. (Note: I like both Carlyle and Getzlaf. I actually think the way Carlyle rides Getzlaf, riding in every sense, is more entertaining/interesting/helpful than just praising a young star player. At least I enjoy it.)







Monday, June 04, 2007

3rd Period Live-Blogging

Pierre informs his audience that Pronger and some of the other Ducks not in uniform tonight do not plan to let Daniel Alfredsson get a free pass. Good for them, but a reminder to Pronger and the Anaheim boys: The Cup matters. Win the game on the scoreboard. Keep Alfredsson from getting his hands on the prize.

(Note to self: My "good for them" reveals that my embrace of hockey culture is not as starkly different from that of Cherry or Hull as I would like to delude myself into believing. I might be an American, slightly more refined fan, but a hockey fan who doesn't believe in sticking up for your teammates? You won't find a real one.)

Brad May's "screaming louder" than Pierre has ever heard him scream has helped to result in an Anaheim goal. Pretty. Tic-tac-toe. Or just tic-tac. Selanne to Penner. Emery is mouthing and angry. Also a nice sight.

An aside: During this commercial break, I feel it should be noted that I rooted for the Senators to beat the Devils, and that while I was rooting for Daniel Briere to lift the Cup, I wasn't all that upset that the Senators beat the Sabres. I was especially happy for the 3-year-old child, the Ottawa fan, who recently passed away, who was able to see his Senators win the conference finals. Such a story was heartwarming and uplifting, honestly and truly and really.

But I can't root for the team that booted my Pens from the playoffs to win the Cup. I just can't. And besides, I've always had something of a soft spot for the Finnish Flash. I'd rather see Teemu get his name on the Cup than Daniel Alfredsson.

One-goal Game: Yes, Mike, as much as I love you, I know it's a one-goal game. That's why my heart's racing. And it's not even a deciding game. And my team isn't even playing. If and when (I hope) my Pens get to this point in a couple of/few seasons, I guess I'm going to have to do a lot of push-ups or running in place or jumping jacks so there's some logical reason for my heart to be racing the way it is. And you know what I said about overtime? I'm okay if the game ends 3-2 in regulation. Which probably means it won't. I don't think things generally happen when I say "I'm okay" if something particular happens.

Growl: Did Pierre really just have to say that Jiggy was playing well? It always seems to me these announcers "jinx" goalies. Or maybe that was just Steigy and Errey (FSN Pittsburgh TV guys) this postseason/at times during the regular season. Still, no jinxing, please.

Pierre: Pierre informs us Randy Carlyle has calmed down, a little, when it comes to his kids (I call them kids, not children. The Pens' kids are the only children, said, of course, in fun). He's showing confidence in his players, even the youth. Interesting how coaching tactics, in terms of how a coach relates to players, change from the beginning to the end of the season, and from the regular season to the postseason. Nothing earth-shattering there, just an observation.

Pierre, Take 2: Bonehead Bill McCreary (hmm, like that alliteration, too, as the only bozos can be the commentating team) tells the Anaheim bench to watch their changes. Edzo almost flips (I mean, for Edzo, it's close to flipping), protesting that Anaheim just did a great job with a change. Well, I mean, anything would have to be better than deliberately putting yourself down a man for no apparent reason (Game 3, remember that, anyone?). If Anaheim has 5 players on the ice when they should, that's a good thing. And, snark aside, Penner scoring on Selanne's pass, that was a nice change for Carlyle's Ducks.

Ottawa Time-Out: Growl, Ottawa called a time out. We're under the 2 minute mark, and my heart is racing, and again, these are so not my teams. Time to start working out (having not done that yet today) at least there's an excuse for the racing heart.

Less Than a Minute: And Emery's out of the net. Jiggy makes a save, but there is too much time left. As there always is in a one-goal game. And oh yes, the heart is still racing, and not just because I started doing lunges.

Anaheim players jump up: On their bench, with less than 2 seconds left in the game. And I start jumping with them. I can't help it. I don't like Ottawa's coach or their captain.

Signing off for the night: There will be no live-blogging of NBC's online coverage. Sorry. When it's on TV, then we'll discuss live-blogging that. Speaking of which, the network had dang well better not cut out of the Stanley Cup final presentation. (Talk about low expectations, eh.)
2nd Intermission Live Blogging

Grapes is here. Awesome. Seriously.

--Danny Alfredsson took a slap shot AT Scott Niedermayer? And I missed that with the mute button on? If Alfredsson did that deliberately--good grief. That's nonsense. There's a reason Scottie's a winner of multiple Cups and you're not, Danny.

--If that was deliberate, I'll wait for some other European to captain a Cup winner. I'll take Jagr's Rangers winning the Cup before Alfredsson does. Shooting the puck AT a future Hall of Famer? Are you a punk? Seriously, you must be a punk.

--Brett Hull as NHL commissioner? Don Cherry as NHL commissioner? Well, things could always be worse (and that's not snark, I'm very serious. Seriously.)

--Brett Hull is back to being a blunt Bozo. Memo to Brett: Shields do not make a player weak. Shields do not make a player a pussy, wussy, or whatever else you'd like to say on TV that you can't. Shields should be MANDATORY for players who are entering the league. Protect players' eyes and their eyesight. Use some common sense.

--I'm the older sibling of a goalie. When people are shooting pucks at my brother at ridiculous rates of speed, I like him to have the best equipment possible. As it is, and as a part of hockey, he's still suffered injuries. There is no need to shrink goalie equipment to put NHL goalies, junior goalies, or college goalies, at unnecessary risk. Of course some goalie equipment has been outlandish. But let's be real: Goalies are better now than they used to be. There are fewer goalie positions available, and expansion hasn't diluted the talent pool as much. Likewise, goalies get much better training in technique than they did in previous generations. Shrinking goalie equipment to a point that points goalies at risk for injury is just silly stupidity--and it's also silliness to think that goalies would suddenly stop using technique and studying videotape and staying in shape just because goalie equipment would shrink. Hate to break it to Brett the Bozo, but slightly smaller goalie equipment is not going to result in more goals. It's just not.

--Hull and Grapes think fighting has a place in the game. I agree with them. Fighting is a part of hockey, and honestly, fighting does help to keep players honest. (Georges Laraque has an important role to play on a regular season Pittsburgh team.) However, if, as Hull and Grapes appear to be claiming, the instigator rule scares teams off--okay, fine. But if something egregious (by egregious, I mean dangerous) happens, then a team has to take their lumps which, of course, is a little easier to stomach in the regular season. Of course all of this talk of "keeping order" could be maintained if the referees would just call the rulebook. But you'll have to get back to me when National Hockey League refs actually start calling the rulebook (and yes, that last sentence was entirely snark).

--Grapes and Hull fighting over Alfredsson's goal was hysterical. I loved to watch Brett being razzed about the goal in the crease. But again, in all seriousnes, I'm easily amused. And while usually screaming that has no point (particularly when it's Yinzers talking about Stillers football) bothers me, I was at least mildly entertained. I guess I enjoy watch Bozo Brett being mocked. I also enjoy Grapes being challenged. It's lovely.

--Grapes talks about Chris Neil diving like it's the end of the world. "I mean, when players like Chris Neil start diving..." What? Jaromir Jagr doesn't dive. Players like Chris Neil do dive. Whether Grapes likes it or not, character guys like Chris Neil are not flawless, no matter how well they play the "Canadian" game.

--Brett Hull wants officials with NHL or junior experience. I want officials who actually call the game. Here's the problem, and I've seen it for years because I've been blessed to watch Lemieux, Jagr, and Crosby. (No comments about how spoiled I am. I am aware of the privilege I've had and still have.) With players like Jagr and Crosby, honestly, hooks and trips could be called at least every other shift (and that's putting things mildly). Crosby and Jagr both have the strength to maintain control of the puck and stay upright, for the most part, but penalties go uncalled when players like Crosby and Jagr fail to embellish. It's old news, and I've been screaming about it, at least, since I was twelve (back in 1994). No matter who's on the ice, the officials must be trained to call a hook as a hook or interference or roughing as it is--no matter if the player has the amazing skillset to fight through whatever the illegal play is.

Too often NHL officials are just like the NHL higher-up's. Andy McDonald didn't get hurt; no suspension. Chris Pronger gave an opponent a concussion. The NHL suspended Pronger. The NHL suspended not just for the action but for the result of the action. In games, NHL officials call the result of the action (a player lying on the ice) far too frequently than they actually call what happened. NHL officials have to be trained to see what happens and not just the result (oh, Crosby still has the puck, yawn).

I realize I just said NHL officials have to be trained. Who's doing the training? The NHL. Yeah. Good luck on that. Maybe in.... Oh, let me be real. Grapes or Hull will be commissioner before that happens.
2nd Period Live Blogging Continued

--Phone call. The TV has to be muted.

--The mute button is magic. Andy McDonald scores another goal. Without hearing commentary, I don't think that's a goal the Senators (and Ray Emery) should be giving up.

--Momentum switches fast in the playoffs; this game is by no means over. But you've got to love a goal that hushes a crowd that's already quiet.

--Talk about more switching of momentum. Heatley scores. Growl. I don't like natural goal scorers who are wingers. Particularly because my Penguins do not have them.

--If I'm Anaheim, I'm not happy Alfredsson and Heatley are on the board. If I'm Ottawa, I'm happy they're on the board. And by the way, Chris Pronger's absence is not coincidental when it comes to Heatley and Alfredsson finally getting untracked.

(Still, if Anaheim could somehow pull this out, even with Ottawa's big guys getting untracked, well, that would bode well. I would think.)

--End of the period festivities. Lots of grabbing and talking. And to that Ottawa buffoon bothering Scott Niedermayer, leave Scott Niedermayer alone. He's better than you. He's above you. Leave Scott Niedermayer alone.

--Eventually the players depart for their respective locker rooms. And Scott Niedermayer starts "talking." Sure, that's what he's doing. Did I not tell that Senator to let Scott Niedermayer be Scott Niedermayer? I mean. Really.

--Tied at 2 all after 2. Maybe I get overtime tonight? Pretty, pretty please?

Period 2 -- Live Blogging

The Lecture: Now Bill McCreary decides to tell Ray Emery that flopping outside of his crease in unacceptable. I wonder what Ryan Getzlaf thinks about that? Somehow I think Sidney's Crosby favorite word (at least the one he's typically caught on camera saying) is probably involved. Good thing no one's got a camera on Getzlaf. Wouldn't be family friendly TV.


Referee Rant: I don't like Bill McCreary. Never have. Come to think of it, I'm not sure I've ever liked an official. Maybe it's because I also rooted for the Mario or Jagr-led Pens, who were never really, to put it mildly, the darlings of referees. The only official I ever liked was one Kevin Collins, a linesman who officiated some of big-time Pens' games, and who I nicknamed Curtis just because, well, he looked like a Curtis.

(Note to self and to anyone who's reading: In any case you hadn't figured it out by now, I'm a little goofy/crazy/other synonyms, and there's no snark involved in that.)

But seriously, I liked Curtis (Kevin Collins) because he always just did his job. He dropped the puck. He called off-sides when it was supposed to be called. He broke up fights.

When it comes to Curtis, though, I never noticed him because he was NOT doing his job. Curtis was always just a part of the game. The game wasn't about Curtis; Curtis was a part of ensuring the game ran smoothly. And most games with Curtis--and not just because the Pens won--did run smoothly.

If I could wish upon a star.....the NHL standard would be Curtis. Officials who call the game right and do their jobs and as such, we only notice them as part of the game--not as the ones who decide the game. Were I to dream, dream, dream, dream....



Baseball Jokes: Ha, ha, ha. Mike Emerick, like me, roots for the pathetic Pirates, who I think are still in contention in the Comedy Central Division in the NL despite a sub .500 record. Edzo jokes about the Pirates' bullpen (it's been VERY BAD lately, blowing leads here and there and everywhere). Yeah, I know it's irrelevant to the game. But these guys know each other and get along and I got the joke and--wow, I'm praising the announcers.

Must. Stop. Now.


Thank you, Mr. Emerick: For apologizing when you made a mistake. Rather than insisting you were right. Players, coaches, and general managers, not to mention on-ice and off-ice bigwigs, could learn a lot from you. When you thought a call was a goal, you didn't insist that it was. You apologized. Thank you for setting a remarkable example. I (no snark here) seriously encourage others in the hockey world to follow Mr. Emerick's example.

Shot Clock Update: The Ducks came to play in Period 2, or they channelled all that rage in the right direction, or something, at least that's what the shot clock says. The momentum has shifted in this period...for how long?

Goal: Andy McDonald, whom Brian Burke, who used to have Colin Campbell's job, jumped so vigorously to protect, scores a goal.

Tie Game. Yeah. The Senators crowd is quiet. Beautiful.
1st Intermission Live-Blogging

"Replacing Pronger": C'mon. Let's be honest. This is what happens with a suspension to a star player, or an injury to a star player. Someone, or many someones in this case, have to take this certain star player's ice time. But these players will not, cannot, and should not be expected to "replace" Chris Pronger. Do you want Ric Jackman trying to dish out a nasty check when he clearly has no concept of how to do that and remain in appropriate defensive position? Duh. Of course not. You want your players who are replacing your star player to play to the best of their abilities, within, of course, their limitations. While I was too busy blogging to pay a ton of attention to the defenseman the Bozo's the Clown called out, I usually diagnose this problem as a player trying to do too much and then not doing what he can do. Beauchemin needs to play within his limitations and not pretend to be someone (cough, Chris Pronger, cough) he isn't.

"We're going to keep playing the same way": Chris Pronger gives Anaheim an edge that the team maintains even when Pronger isn't on the ice. However, I'm not sure that it's wise, e.g., in Anaheim's case, to continue to make the plays that referees are calling as penalties. When a key cog in the wheel is missing, other adjustments have to be made to ensure the bike can still function. (Snark to myself: Yes, that's a horrible analogy. Deal with it.) And perhaps for Anaheim that might need to be tweaks to the basic approach (tweaks, not a wholesale overhaul) in order to give the Prongerless Ducks a better shot at winning.

Oh, dear, I am going to break a record: Bozo Brett is far more blunt than I am. But I agree with Brett's basic premise. For all I could rightfully criticize certain Anaheim Ducks, the men in stripes were probably the worst offenders, when it comes to doing their jobs well, during the first period.

Scott Niedermayer: The Bozos praise Scotty. How could not? His name is Scott. He plays defense. He's a future Hall of Famer. Oh, yeah, and he played like such. Nice job, Scottie. Still, if you and Jiggy are the only ones who come to play, I think this series shifts back to Anaheim tied at 2. But the announcers and I agree again (seriously: this is NOT that common).

Don Cherry Preview: I am promised Don Cherry is coming. Good. Grapes and I rarely agree on anything. (I love Jordan Staal, too, but I still think Evgeni Malkin should win the Calder Trophy.) The Bozos joke about Cherry's suits. It's kind of funny. You know, if ex-hockey players discussing wardrobe/attire issues is funny to you. I'm pretty easy to amuse.
Live-Blog: Game 4

Caveat: I've never previously done live-blogging. To ease the stress (snark: I wouldn't blog if I found it stressful), I think I'm just going to focus on Bozo the Clowns (specifically the pre-game and intermission commentators). And Don Cherry. And whatever else I feel like blogging about.

--It's raining in Ottawa. No snow? This isn't Edmonton in early June. Disappointing.

--The trio of Bozo's the Clown make their first appearance. Bill Clement facilitates the top 2 Bozos talking.

--Ferraro says Pronger should have been suspended. Hull yells at Anaheim fans and says Pronger should NOT have been suspended.

--Note to Brett: Honey, are you really that desperate to be liked? Perhaps you don't really like to be hated?

--Note to self: Wow, did Bozo Brett really just make sense? Hull has a good point here. Regardless of the ultimate result, if the NHL wants to punish illegal hits to the head, then the NHL needs to punish all illegal hits to the head. Even if such an illegal hit results in no injury, punishment should now be forthcoming. (I think I could agree that MORE punishment should result when injuries result.)

--Chris Neil rant: Chris Neil wants to call Chris Pronger a "backstabber"? Chris Pronger has more talent in his rebuilt-from-surgery wrist than Chris Neil could ever dream of having. Of course, I'm happy for Neil, what with the birth of his first child and an appearance in the Cup Finals. (Not snark here. I would hope Neil would be having a blast at this particular life juncture.) But memo to Chris Neil: You and Chris Pronger share more in common that just your first names. You play the same "on-edge" style. The only difference is that Pronger is a perennial Norris Trophy winner who's also won a Hart Trophy, and Chris Neil is, well, that character guy who's good in the locker room.

(Reflective note in midst of live-blogging: My natural loathing for Chris Neil appears here. Wow.)

--I like Mike Fisher (his forechecking prowess against my Pens notwithstanding). He's articulate and smart. Why is he friends with Chris Neil? Ah, what that whole "team concept" can do. Mike Fisher and Chris Neil, polar opposites on the ice (I don't really think Chris Neil is THAT smart of a player, sorry), can be friends. Life's amazing.

Random Comment: I understand all about advertising, really, I do. It's not like the NHL has a decent American TV contract anyway (a whole other topic for a whole other time). But really, let's be honest. The officials deliver the game-puck on time, not any company. And it's not like NHL officials deliver the puck on time anyway, not with the pregame festivities of listening to Bozo 1, 2, and 3, and the beautiful spectacle (no snark, I mean this) of the Canadian and American national anthems being sung.

Canadian bias? Or blind eyes? Or just Chris Neil is a punk. Ottawa fans who claimed Sidney Crosby dived need to wake up and smell the roses. Or at least honestly admit that their lovely, edgy character guy, just took a ridiculous dive. Yes, Chris Neil is so huge and strong and tough that he throws himself on the ice. Diving like that doesn't get you called a "backstabber," rather, but that hockey insult, pure and simple, of "diver."

(Oh, and this is weird, because Edzo and I didn't agree on much when he was Pittsburgh's coach. But it wasn't exactly like Edzo had all that much to work with as Pittsburgh's coach last season, so it wasn't like we had a lot, really, about which to disagree. But the point is: I agree with an announcer for the 2nd time tonight. Chris Neil dove. Wow. I'm far more astounded by the fact an announcer and I share an opinion than by the earth-shattering (snark) news that Chris Neil is a diver.)

Update: At least the Ducks killed that stupid penalty.

The Anaheim Parade to the penalty box: Canadian bias aside (in all seriousness, from where do the majority of NHL officials hail?), I might be in for a record. I think Pierre just told the Ducks to play their game and forget Chris Neil. Just to be difficult, I'd like to tell Anaheim: play your game, without boneheaded penalties, as much as possible, and in so doing, you will get Chris Neil. Eventually. Where it matters. By winning.

Maybe this will have to be a new feature. Keep track of my record for agreeing with the announcing "team." But I do agree the Ducks will miss Pronger on the PK.

A beautiful, and just sight: Chris Neil is in the penalty box. It's a beautiful thing, baby. Absolutely wonderful.

On the ensuing Anaheim PP, Scott Niedermayer gets the Sidney Crosby/Chris Pronger treatment.
Memo to Senators fans: C'mon. Crosby is the best player in the game at nineteen. And Pronger's not just scary good, he plays with that dirty edge you love in Chris Neil but hate in the opposition. But booing Scott freakin' Niedermayer? He was a Devil for years, and I hated him, but c'mon, Scott Niedermayer screams class.

Helpful PP tips: It might be a good idea for Anaheim to use their PP to get shots on Ottawa's goalie rather than allowing another class act, Mike Fisher, to get a shot on Jiggy. Fortunately, Jiggy has made the saves he's had to make so far in this game.

Shot Clock Check: Anaheim finally gets a shot. Wow. More than halfway through the first period, welcome to Game 4 of the Cup Finals, Anaheim Ducks.

Wow: I can't quite recall which losing version of the Penguins on which Ric Jackman was featured on the Pittsburgh blueline, but suffice it to say the Pens had a few years (insert reminder that the Pens made the playoffs for 11 consecutive years prior to those years) where they earned the right, on merit of wretchedly awful (not just merely bad) play, to draft two of this year's Calder Trophy nominees. In any case, several Pens' message boarders (seriously now: is there a better term?) moaned about letting the "great" Ric Jackman leave. Still, watching Jackman on the ice at the same time as Teemu Selanne. No offense to Jackman and no matter what great thing he might yet go on to do, but Ric Jackman and Teemu Selanne do not belong on the same sheet of ice.

Quality Drop-Off: You can't help but notice the huge gap in talent level that exists between #1 and #5-7 defensemen. When Scott Niedermayer leaves the ice, it's not like Anaheim just twirl out another #1 defenseman. And that does make a difference. Those #5-7 defensemen have to keep the play simpler, and they sure as heck do not provide the same support to Selanne's line and the "Kid" line as would Norris Trophy winners. Granted, of course this is probably a "duh" moment. But just know that as a Pittsburgh Penguins fan whose blueline depth was the team's weakest link all year, it's a little odd to see Anaheim's lower level blueliners reminding me of the limited skillsets of Joe Melichar and Rob Scuderi.

(Um, obviously, in any case anyone doesn't get it, Anaheim's blueline is far superior to Pittsburgh's. It's just that, well, all defense corps, especially those headlined by 2 legitimate #1 defenseman, have an obvious quality dropoff from #1 to #7 on the depth chart.)

Funny Emerick Story: Emerick tells a story about Kerry Fraser officiating some game that wasn't a NHL game. At least that's what I think.
Note to self: Blogging and watching the game simultaneously is fun, but it does mean I can't attend to Mike Emerick's stories as I usually can. Not that I necessarily do. But say this for Emerick, who narrated those 1991 and 1992 Stanley Cup videos I memorized as a kid. He's got some great hockey stories to tell.
Other note to self: Ah, Kerry Fraser. He wasn't allowed to officiate in the playoffs. Seeing the (snark warning) high level of officiating in these playoffs, one has to wonder how much worse (seriously now) the officiating would be if Fraser had been officiating any of these playoff games.

Dang: Just as I was about to type that the Ducks owed Jiggy a beer for every save he made that period, Ottawa's captain scores a goal. Of course the class act (still serious) Fisher makes the play in the corner that helps that goal get scored. The Ducks still owe Jiggy 12 beers for keeping them in a period in which they were outshot 13-2. But the Ducks had better wait until the Finals end before they buy Jiggy those beers. Jiggy's sure going to need to be sharp if the Ducks start making a pattern of playing every period like period 1 of Game 4.

Media Manners? or Blunt Honesty: Ryan Getzlaf shows that he has yet to go to the Sidney Crosby school of media manners, e.g., having one personality on the ice and a much more, er, nuanced personality as soon as it's time to talk to a reporter. Getzlaf informs Pierre that the call was horrible and complains about the officiating while also admitting that this type of officiating isn't exactly new. I'm sure Pierre, like me, appreciates Getzlaf's blunt honesty. And now a little advice for the Ducks: channel that frustration and energy into, you know, shooting the puck at Ray Emery. Seriously. It would be good for your frustrations. And better for the shot clock.

(Memo to Getzlaf: I'm only a little older than you, but NHL officiating has been like this for a very, very, long time.)


Oh, and: Just a reminder, something I forgot about, but I really dislike Ottawa's coach. He's a whiner and a cryer and a complainer, and I've never liked him. I'm not sure I quite remember my history with him (did he coach a playoff team that lost to my Pens?), but I know I have never liked him. Whining and crying, especially in a coach, is highly unattractive. Motivate your players and strategize. Do what Scott Bowman did when he told the '92 Pens NOT to retaliate to the '92 New York Rangers--but don't work the officials from the bench or in the press. It's annoying, and it's not where winning coaches should focus their energy or effort. But, really, what do I expect Murray to know about winning? There's a reason Murray is Murray and Bowman's the winningiest coach in NHL history.

Sunday, June 03, 2007

Chris Pronger=Ulf Samuelsson?

At first glance, to the hockey fan such an equivalency, even a rough one, appears patently absurd. Yet, in a conversation this week, the comparison was explored. And, upon further merit, the comparison is not quite as outlandish as it would appear at first blush.

First, to deal with the objections. Yes, of course Chris Pronger has played, for the most part, in a different NHL than the one in which Ulf Samuelsson played. And yes, of course Chris Pronger is far more of a complete defenseman than Ulf Samuelsson ever was. Pronger can body-check, kill penalties, but he can also play more than half of a 60 minute game because he is (to put it mildly) an effective power play quarterback who excels at such things as the outlet pass and keeping the puck in at the blue line. Honestly and upfront, it must be acknowledged that Pronger always has and always will be a more complete defenseman than was Ulf Samuelsson, even in Samuelsson's heyday.

However, Pronger and Samuelsson share certain similarities that--whether you loved or hated Samuelsson or adore or abhor Pronger--had the potential to make both of them extremely effective defensemen in the postseason.

Nasty: Just as Samuelsson physically punished his opposition, so, too, does Pronger physically punish his opposition. And here I am not necessarily talking about those "borderline" plays, but just about the fact that when it comes to bruising bodychecks, Pronger and Samuelsson share that both defensemen hit, and hit with full-force.

Edge: Playing with an edge goes beyond being merely nasty. In his prime, Samuelsson was as edgy as they came. Samuelsson would do whatever was necessary to give his team the competitive advantage, although he had to learn how to maintain control in critical situations. Likewise, Pronger has always played with a fierce, competitive edge, and while the 2006 playoffs showed he'd grown leaps and bounds in terms of controlling his edgy play, Pronger, like Samuelsson, will always play on the edge.

Borderline Dirty/Just Plain Dirty/Cheap Shot Artists: All of the above charges were levelled against Ulf Samuelsson. All of the above charges have been levelled against Pronger during the 2007 postseason. As for Samuelsson, well, he is blamed for prematurely ending the career of the great Boston power forward Cam Neely with knee-on-knee hits. Pronger is accused of using his elbows (e.g. which are higher than other people's elbows, thank you very much, Brian Burke and Randy Carlyle) to give hits from behind that result in concussions to the opposition. Pronger is basically accused of head-hunting.


Whether fans of Ulf Samuelsson or Chris Pronger like it or not, all three of the above "charges," but in particular, the last, have merit. While I heard a comment that this week where a longtime hockey fan wondered aloud if all "real" defenseman (e.g. not rovers, primarily offensive stars a la Paul Coffey) were a bit borderline dirty anyway. Over the course of their careers, at various times, the "dirty" charge was levelled against players like Scott Stevens and Chris Chelios, too. And frankly speaking, from a "rational", e.g., as unbiased as possible perspective, Chris Pronger and Ulf Samuelsson share this in common: At minimum, throughout their careers, such players have committed acts that rightfully have them labeled, minimally, as borderline dirty players.

Yet there is one more category that both Chris Pronger and Ulf Samuelsson share, and it is what I have now dubbed the "Sidney Crosby treatment."

Universally Loathed by the Opposition/Universally Loved by the Home Team:
If an effective Pronger in his prime or Samuelsson in his prime is starring for your particular team, you love them. I make no bones about this. Go to any Edmonton Oilers blog and read the masses of adoring odes to Pronger throughout the 2005-06 season and 2006 postseason. Read the vitriol spewed by fans of opposing teams toward Pronger last season and this season. Pronger is pretty much universally detested, just as Ulf Samuelsson was in his heyday.

As a Pens fan who rooted for a team laden with future HHOF talent, Ulf Samuelsson stood out from the typical Pens star. But make no mistake about it: The man they called Ulf was a star in his own right. Ulfie thrilled the Penguins faithful and was adored and respected by his teammates. He was a nightmare for opponents and a dream come true for the home team. Oh, and his nasty edge and consistent defense helped to provide a backbone to two Stanley Cup winning teams that probably, in all honesty, never could have captured the Cup without his play solidifying a group of out-of-this-world offensive stars.

When I watched the start of Game 3 of the Finals, it occurred to me that Ottawa fans were giving Chris Pronger what I have come to refer to as the Sidney Crosby treatment. I briefly wondered if the Canadian faithful were upset that Pronger demanded a trade from another Canadian team last summer. And, then, of course, I snapped to my senses. Say whatever I will for Ottawa fans, but fans in Canada's capital know hockey. They knew that without Pronger having a "forgettable Game 3,: as an AP article later noted, that their team was likely to be down in a pretty much insurmountable 3-0 hole. They knew that Pronger, just like Crosby, had the ability to impact a game, and in impacting a game, alter the course of a series.

Of course, muddled in with the acknowledgement that players who've been nominated at some point in their careers for MVP trophies merit a bit of fearful backlash from opposing fans, so too must the acknowledgement come that with Pronger comes not just the "Sidney Crosby treatment" but the "Ulf Samuelsson treatment." Sure, opposing fans boo Crosby and Pronger because they know such star players can hurt the home team. But fans boo Pronger not just because he can hurt the home team on the scoreboard. They boo Pronger, the way they booed Samuelsson, because Pronger has shown that he can, quite literally, hurt the opposing players.

So is Ulf Samuelsson to Chris Pronger really a fair comparison, a decent equivalency? Honestly. No, not quite. Very few players are blessed to play on teams as talented as the Pittsburgh teams that captured Cups at the start of the nineties, but Samuelsson did. And in winning those Cups, Samuelsson forever etched himself among players who will always be "universally adored" by Penguins fans.

And until Pronger captures a Cup, whether it's fair or not, and this despite his overall far higher skill level than Ulf Samuelsson, as in potentially Hall of Fame skill level, Pronger's "borderline dirty" attributes will never outweigh his ridiculously obscene skillset, even in the eyes of the home team that adores him.

But if and when Pronger captures a Cup, well, of course anyone who actually stumbled upon this blog will read this post and roll their eyes. Because Pronger is a far more complete player than Ulf Samuelsson ever was, but both defensemen share certain attributes that opposing fans (to put it politely) loathe. Unfortunately for Pronger, players of his ilk are measured by championships won, and not just by how close they came to winning a championship.

All that being said, however, including the statement that Pronger has been, is, and probably will always remain an obscenely skilled but borderline dirty player, I'd still welcome him, or a player like him, to my Pittsburgh Penguins. Our blueline and our team of youthful, speedy stars, could surely use an edge on the blueline. And, as far as "dirty players" go, 2 Stanley Cup victories helped to ensure that Ulf Samuelsson will remain universally loved in Pittsburgh.

Saying everything I've said about Pronger in this post, perhaps the best thing I can say is that I would still take him on my team, and that I still agree with his coach Randy Carlyle that his positive attributes (as a complete defenseman) far outweigh his negative attributes. Of course I wouldn't want Pittsburgh GM Shero sacrificing any of the Pens' future to obtain Pronger or a player of his age who is like him, at least not at this juncture in the team's development.

But the 1991 and 1992 Pens would not have won their Cups without Ulf Samuelsson, just as the Ducks will not win a Cup this season without Chris Pronger. And in order for captain Sidney Crosby to win the Cup someday, the Pens' blueline will need to feature at least one defenseman who plays shutdown defense with the kind of edge and grit and meanness found in both Ulf Samuelsson and Chris Pronger.

Cheap shot artists? Borderline dirty, at minimum? Absolutely.

Shut down defensemen without whom a team can't hope to capture a Cup? You bet.

Ulfie and Prongs share negative attributes, but those who have lustfully booed realized that they weren't just booing plain old cheap shot artists. They were booing impact players, star players, even, who--even when going way too overboard--more often than not, still manage to be a part of what makes an already-good team a great team.
The Rulebook

Clarification is Sorely Needed


It is not often when I find myself in agreement with Bozo the Clown 1, 2, and 3 (as I tend to refer to the national commentators on NBC or Versus broadcasts. Snark warning: Be glad I don't watch Don Cherry. I doubt I'd be as polite, and of course, it's all in jesting fun).

In all seriousness, aside from hits to the head--a matter which at least, according to the Hockey News, the NHL has promised to discuss this offseason--the league has got to do something about this "distinct kicking motion" rule.

Frankly speaking, I've seen too many goals this postseason (I'm sure they occurred during the regular season, but the playoffs trump all) scored or not scored by that "distinct kicking motion." The rule, or at least the interpretation of the rule, is a mess.

Questions I've asked, Comments I've had:

  • Was that player really just trying to stop and the puck inadvertently went in off his skates? And if that's the case, why is that goal a goal, and in another case, it was ruled not a goal? Talk about inconsistency!
  • Was that a "distinct kicking motion?" It depends on your interpretation. Who's doing the interpreting, and why is the interpretation different? Why is what appears to be the same exact incident resulting in a goal at one game and a disallowed goal at another game? The lack of consistency is baffling and annoying?

  • If players don't know what a goal is, and if coaches don't know what a goal is, and if these Bozo the Clown experts who, I will concede, have played the game, can't tell what a goal is, well, how in the world can anyone else?

  • Would the NHL, once and for all, please, please, pretty please, ensure the rulebook makes sense and can be accurately and consistently applied in every situation? Seriously. Please? Pretty, pretty, please?

All my questioning and commentary aside, the fact of the matter is that this rule has to be clarified. As much as I love all the stuff the new captain of my team, and currently the best player in the NHL, can do with his feet, a part of me wonders if the NHL needs to enforce something as simple as this: You must shoot the puck in the net, with your stick, to score a goal. (Now, of course deflections off the other's team's defensemen, sticks, skates, would be permissible.)

Yet even the league doesn't need a statement that simple, it surely needs something better than the inconsistency to which coaches, players, and fans have been subjected throughout the entire postseason. For the pure purposes of fair competition, I plead with the NHL: clarify the rule. Please.

No, it won't ensure longer careers or safety on the ice. But being able to know what the rules are can only help sell the sport to new fans. Beyond that, however, it's just common sense.

(Snark Warning: Any guesses as to how long it will take for the NHL to apply common sense to solve a problem?)